Skip to main content

Typo, myopia, or poor execution?


This posting is the first part of two stories about what I think are examples of poor marketing execution. Today, companies spend millions of dollars in new ways not only to creatively engage consumers, but also in establishing a long term relationship with them. Despite all their efforts, some still fall short in ensuring their marketing efforts are executed to perfection. If these efforts happen to fail in the long run, the entire marketing department is there to be blamed. Sometimes simple mistakes in executing the final stages of a program can cost the entire failure of the marketing program. Often times, the planning, research, and strategy stages of a marketing plan are the first ones to be scrutinized for not "getting in right" from the beginning, but executing correctly a plan is as important, if not more than the stages of its conception because that is what consumers ultimately will experience at the point of sell or service.

Two weeks ago, I went to the Nissan dealership to take my car to its regular oil change service. Usually, I bring a book with me, grab a cup of coffee, and sit down and wait about 30 to 45 minutes for the service to be completed. Every time I go there, I also like take a look at the new cars they have at showroom. This time I remember looking at a beautiful red 300 Z, when suddenly a salesman vigorously approached me and start explaining all the car features. He gave me his card and I thanked him. I also told him that I was just looking around. As I was heading back to the waiting room, I looked at his business card and read "Se Habela Espanol." I didn't know if I should laugh or go tell him that his card had a big typo. Instead, I stopped and said to myself. "We are in 2008, I think by know most of the salesmen people, especially in Texas should know Spanish and also should know that it is Habla and not Habela." I also thought that it could've been a simple typo; nonethelsess, I noticed that the name of the salesman was Caesar and not Cesar, as I remember it is normally spelled. I don't know what it was, but if a company like Nissan spends big dollars on Spanish advertising, or hires sales people that are supposedly bilingual, so that they can better communicate with the Latino community. Why not double check that all your efforts are being executed correctly? I don't want to be paranoid or anything, but I think that sometimes these little mistakes in execution can turn off people who really appreciates their heritage and language, and thus return as customers.

Comments

  1. WOW, what a story!!!
    It really makes you wonder how many people or potential customers have noticed that little ‘typo,’ and how many have been turned off. The most interesting thing that came to mind while reading your posting was not even in relation to Nissan, but was in relation to the ‘Caesar’ or ‘Cesar’ brand.
    Whenever you are in the market for a new or used car for that matter, you want to have the most knowledgeable sales person… why? Because you want to be able to get the best car possible. Anyway knowing that Caesar claims to know Spanish, but doesn’t know how to write it makes me doubt his sale expertise. Fine, if he wants to be known as Caesar that is ok, that is a different struggle that he chooses to have (the Latino vs non-Latino name), but I definitely don’t want him selling me a car in my language when he clearly doesn’t even know how to speak it….
    While doing research for a bank in Dallas I remember a comments that speaks to a very true Hispanic insight.
    “I speak enough English to get around… but when speaking business, I speak Spanish.”
    Going back to your main point about poor execution…
    If only Nissan knew… but that is the problem with franchisees. A good example happened to the Jack in the Box in Juarez, Mexico, and a McDonald’s in Russia. Corporate asked them to follow instructions. With Russia I believe it was in relation to the flags, and in Juarez it was about using branded napkins… both didn’t follow the rules, and both were closed. I’m not suggesting that Nissan does this, but I am suggesting that there needs to be someone caring about the brand at this level…
    It’s not about micromanaging, it’s about brand managing.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Its the explanation of the phenomena that gives the insight...

I have always found the following idea among the most interesting in business: numbers = true insight. Strong statement right?! Depending on where you stand, Positivist or Post, you might say that the above statement is true. Now, dont get me wrong, I enjoy numbers (a lot actually), but I feel that businesses nowadays are hanging thei hat on a percentage. Some examples of things I've heard - "Our brand tracking is showing that our awareness has declines 2%... are our TV not working?"  "The advertising strategy is not really moving product (sales)... I really haven't seen a percentage increase..." And I could honestly keep giving examples, but the above two are some I can recall pretty fast. Now, let me say that there is nothing wrong with the above statements, what bothers me is that with numbers we tend to look for one answer and one answer only. The thinking behind this is that there has to be some variable that is affecting the phenomena.But, if the...

Is this not a bit too intrusive?!

I know that good marketing is supposed to catch you a bit off guard and make you think about the message but this is just too much... Why? Because, 1) although it in fact was unexpected, it crossed the privacy line (which by today's standards is pretty low). 2) it's not creative, and 3) lacks authenticity... Which is the last thing you want if you deal with money. Thought?!

Honestly... Who is thinking Arby's??

Having worked at a McDonald's and for the McDonald's brand for a couple of years, seeing advertising like the one below reminds why the golden arches still have the higher share in the fast food market. Please know that I am not saying that McD's has this share solely because of its advertising, but at the very least, their advertising doesn't turn anyone away. While watching TV a couple of weeks ago, I came across the Arby's B-day spot, which you can see below. After watching it I just thought... wow, somebody actually produced this spot? Let me say that there is really nothing wrong with the production, it is more the idea that got produced. The strategy behind this campaign was pretty insightful and good. I'm Thinking Arby's . Ownable , different and niche enough that when you want to eat something hot and tasty only Arby's will suffice, hence you crave and can only think Arby's ... the problem was the execution. Does the guy like the food?...